Government needs the power to be able to build great things private or public.
July 4, 2005
A Red Light Runner is Killed: Blaming any one besides those who violate the law is unjust.
Albany's Trailer Park: Fox Run is the forgotten victim of our consumerism.
Albany's Violence Problem: Marginialized and forgotten communities create destructive people.
Albany, 2058: What the future of the Capital City may be like after peak oil.
Bikable Buses: It's great to be able to take you bike on the bus.
Bike to Work Day: On Friday you should ride your bike to work.
Brutalism: Some thoughts on my favorite type of architecture.
Cities, A Modern Future: Poverty and a lack of incentives destroy our cities...
Demolish the Howe Library, Save Troy City Hall !: We should be fair in evaluating old buildings.
Economic Development: The fabled search for new employers can be troublesome.
Fires in California: We need wild fires, but when we get too close to nature we may get burned.
More Then $4.2k for Each Albany Resident: That's how much debt the city now has out.
Psychology of Previous Investment : Why Kunstler’s notion is a misnomer in our modern society.
Regionalization: There are two sides to getting governments to work together.
Speeding: It's dangerous, unneccessary, wastes fuel, and kills.
Suburban Life: Not As Evil As Seems: Andrew ponders over a couple of aspects over suburbs and wonders if they are the great evil we sometimes make them out to be.
The Roundabout Review: A look at the new Sligerlands Bypass and it's roundabouts.
The State Butterfly: Politics, Elementary Schools Students, and making the Karner Blue a state symbol.
Two Sides of the Big Cities: Some more reflections on the big city lifestyle.
Eminent Domain is the power of government to take land from an owner without his consent with just compensation and sufficient notice. It is rooted in the Fifth Amendment of the US constitution that specifically prohibits the taking of property for public use without just cause. It does not mention the taking of property for private use or delineate how such powers should be used.
Many of the great projects proposed by government would have been stopped if it were not for eminent domain. Railroads would not have gone through, superhighways would be able to be stopped by the single owners, and great government buildings would never have been built. There are so many things that are in a common interest to the people as a whole that we can not afford to allow single person veto power over. In the future this will be increasingly important as useful land close to our cities get gobbled up.
Eminent domain for private use will increase over the next few years. When cities want to rebuild their downtowns and main streets, they are often going to face opposition by some people who want to continue the status quo without respect to the interest of everybody else. Some people will always refuse to give up their land, despite the wisdom of the state to use it for a bolder public purpose.
Property rights people claim that the biggest corporations and developers will always win. If government works the way that it should, and takes a balanced perspective from public hearings that are held, then big corporations will only win when the facts are compelling on there side. As shown with St. Lawrence Cement, the big company doesn't always win. The community won when it saw that a Greenport plant would have only negatives for the community. Government can work and as such should be given the power to do great things.
Sometimes a Walmart is a good use for a condemned piece of property. People need cheap goods, and they also need jobs. In an area of urban blight, a Walmart might help things out. The same thing might be said about a Walmart in rural area that once was a farm. The reverse is true: government could condemn a Walmart to put a farm back to better protect open space. A private housing development might be the solution to replacing run-down houses in the south-end. The possibilities are nearly endless.
Ultimately, we need a smart government that listens to public input and creates great projects where they are needed. People should not fear their property being condemned and turned into another more appropriate use for the area, but instead should embrace change. At the same time, government must assist those who are dislocated by such change in finding equivalent housing and other necessary things such as counseling, transportation, and moving expenses. If government works for the people and not against them, then a powerful government is a good thing.
![]() | Dairy Farm in Peru From the Farming Series. Added 10/9/06. |
Copyright ©1999-2008 Andy Arthur.
All mistakes are intentional or otherwise.
Mind where you step in a cow pasture or legal mindfield.