Andrew takes another look at the PATRIOT Act.
August 25, 2003
Abortion: The abortion debate is unrealistic and immoral.
Airport Security: Keeping Me Off Planes: Why Andrew is scared to ride planes, with all the security, and crap that people have to go through to get on planes.
America and It's Flag: Thoughts on being an American and the flag means this Memorial Day Weekend.
Confederate Flag: The controversal flag the symbolizes rural freedom.
Facebook and the EAC: Why hiding ourselves on facebook is not a way to build a reputation.
Guns and the Mentally Ill: Some thoughts on reforming gun control in our country.
Internet and Social Change: How the Internet allows for free speech and discussion.
Live Free or Die: Is this existential question of democracy?
Moral Permissiveness: People should consider all thoughts and possibilities, even if they are 'wrong'.
Photography and Privacy: A look at the privacy issues I run into when I take photos.
Rural Means Free: As there are fewer people in the country, we can all be more free.
Selling Violence: The media uses Kathina Thomas to sell crappy cars and soap.
She's Come Undone: Commentary on the PATRIOT Act and COINTELPRO.
Stealing: What does it mean to steal in our digital age?
The Second Admendment: Trying to make sense of what the founding founders wrote.
Unfree America: America's lack of freedom in a coming of age, sucks.
Ward Churchill and Hamilton College: Free speech must extend even to those who message bothers us.
Why the 2nd Amendment Matters: Some thoughts on why the right to bear arms is so important.
You Have No Dignity: The lost of a word led to less freedom for all Americans.
Ooh... It's the big bad new PATRIOT Act 2.0. Everybody, let's celebrate this new release and forget about all our other problems. Wasn't version 1.0 all enough fun.
Okay, so now the government is going to watch us all a bunch more carefully. It's a rather boring job to watch some smuck like me all of the time. And that's not to mention how boring it will be to watch some construction worker do his job..
So do you think that the government is coming after you and I? I sure as hell hope so. I want my paranoia to turn out to the be truth. The government loves to chase radicals and try to put them in the place. And like usual, the government plays very well into their games (like that evil late bastard by the name of Jerry Rubin).
Neither PATRIOT Act seems all that super odious to me. I mean, hasn't the government always had these powers, even when they aren't paper. Maybe we are setting precedence or some bullshit like that, but I doubt it.
We aren't a nation of laws and order, despite what some people try to lie to the masses about (how socialist?). Instead we are a nation governed mostly by popular opinion, no matter how remote that may seem from the current public opinion.
I doubt any US Senators will ever be procecuted in by any Patriot Act statue. While many Senators may be terrorists, there certainly not the kind the act intended. Don't forget that courts often consider the intent of an law—not just the exact statue.
And let's not forget the bad public opinion that would create. There would be a line ten miles long of people, wanting to change the law. You upset too many people, then we end up with riots in the streets—and turblence on Capitol Hill. Remember, no faction has enough power to run our country on their own—even the President can't control the armed forces against his own government and people.
If the EPA had written the PATRIOT Act it would have:
Yeah, the second is particularly interesting here. Nobody has tried to apply any kind of utilitarian prinicipal to terrorism. Utilitiarianism would seem super-hard with terrorism—how do calculate the cost of human life or to the economy.
I've always viewed human life as something that's kind of disposable, unlike that stuff that humans create. True, there is no such thing as a clone of a human, and everybody is unique. At a deeper level it would seem the humans are pretty much biodegrable and won't be polluting the earth for the next 20, 100, or 1,000 years like some our inventions will. People come and go, and times change. I don't see many people around from 100 or 150 years ago.
Isn't freedom more important then life? I guess you need life to be free. At least that is what some people claim. O the same grounds, you need life to have slavery.
At any rate, does it make a lot of sense to go crazy about saving a few peoples lives? Blame the safety lobby, that is so loved by conservatives and liberals. Libertarians want to throw us to the sharks. They believe that even inexpensive safe guards are too expensive.
That's always the risk we run if we oppose all terrorism measures. Let see, to stop the terrorism, that seems to hypotetically hits every day, some pretty drastic measures might be taken.
Look at Isreal. Isreal is truly a terrible place (I'm not bashing the Jews), if only because it's a land of drastic measures and terrorism going on every day. Peace is a joke in a land like that and so are civil liberties.
I guess that's the risk we all run.
![]() | From the Coeymans Series. Added 12/27/06. |
Copyright ©1999-2008 Andy Arthur.
All mistakes are intentional or otherwise.
Mind where you step in a cow pasture or legal mindfield.