
A careful analyisis of role of technology and bureaucratic rationality on the world around us.
October 4, 2003
1968: The Start of the Technological Revolution: When did the tech revolution really start?
Affordable Rural Broadband: Some high speed access is out in the country, but it's expensive.
All Hand Coded: I enjoy coding things myself despite all the extra work it creates.
Am I Old Fashioned? Thoughts on Change: Andrew writes about his thoughts on a changing world.
As A Computer Programmer: One of a series of essays on different carrer options and what they entail.
Bureaucracies Have Political Cultures: Despite the image of apolitical life in bureaucracy, the people who make government work are often very political.
Bureaucracy: It's Problems: The reality of bureaucratic thought in our society.
Canned Reality: A discussion of video games, and television, and their effects on society.
DTV: Time To Get Rid of Your TV?: They won't work next year, so recycle 'em, and look to other sources of news.
Email and Spam: Many of us just get too much useless information but at least we don't have to dispose of it.
Highly Urbanized Computing: How Windows XP is not unlike our big cities.
Hudson Valley Not Tech Valley: Our future is in diversity, not technology.
In a Computerized World: Are We Humans Anymore?: Andrew asks if in a computer dominated world, if being a person means anything anymore.
Malta's Reality: Far from being a great tech center, it shows the freedom of rural life.
Nation of Managers: Management is not a solution to our problems.
Post-Modernity: Five areas of study that allow us to see beyond the limits of science and technology.
Running out of Freedom: It sometimes seems like that I've seen everything locally (eventhough I haven't), and that finding cgreener pastures is getting harder.
Simplicity: For the Web, For the World: Simple webpages present information quickly. A simple world makes sure we get that infomation.
Tech Valley Realities: High Tech in Albany won't just give us jobs, it will also change cultures and increase sprawl.
The Endless Freedom Assault of our Technocratic Society: How somehow our fixes to our problems may actually make things worst.
The Parthenon: Technology and Politics: Reviewing the relationship between technology, politics, and a greater society.
The Story of the Non-Programmer: Sometimes thinking about who you have been, can take the stress off a rough day, and the bad memories that a class may bring back.
Tired of Computers? I Don't Think I'm Alone.: After a long semister of dealing with them, and doing lots of school work, he's just plain tired...
Webpages: Keep 'em Simple: We need to have simple webpages that load quickly.
Wireless Internet: Free hotspots make it possible for us to access high speed internet without cost.
Technology and bureaucracy give us a form of control and dominance over nature and man-kind. Max Weber termed this bureaucratic rationality *, a term I often shorten to just 'rationality'. Such technocratic rationality of technology, corporations, and government gives us a lot of new freedoms and the ability to exist as a mass society, but it also comes at the cost of corrupting individual's spirit and demeaning what it means to be human.
To illustrate this point and to critically examine our belief in bureaucratic rationality, I use a dialetical method that contrasts bureaucratic and technological rationality to it's anti-thesis. I call these things the 'rational' and the 'anti-rational' or 'irrational', based on notions from Max Weber and mathematics. You will see my frequently refer to these concepts in my writing, and they play a key concept in my thinking.
Everything in our world is fundamentally 'irrational' and unpredictable **. Man has learned to harnass nature and mankind in a variety of ways, but he come far from controlling it. He simply can not understand fully the complexities of nature and mankind. You should think of the world as not being much different from the mathematical concept of PI, a number that can not be exactly defined except in terms of itself.
Even PI has a degree of predictability, and we can approximate it's meaning through the decimal system. A similiar thing applies to mankind and nature: we understand a lot about it, even while we do not understand or are totally innocent to it's nunances. In the social sciences, we call that concept parsony, a simplication that gives fairly good results, but does not try to overcrowd we details. This blindness can explain much of the contemporary social problems we face, from apathy to environmental pollution to crime on our streets.
As a society, we ought to respect not only what science, technology, and bureaucracy tells us, but also what we percieve to be the truth. We need to look beyond the blinders of the limits of current technology, and try to understand our deeperselves and the world around us. This challenge is essential for our existance as human beings.
Rationality should not be confused with reason. Humans are able to make good judgements when all the facts are kept in perspective. The human existance is uniquely different from rational machines and bureaucratic existance.
* Weber was far more of a proponent of big government, technology, and bureaucratic ratinality then I am. Yet, he was also critical of such bureaucratic-rational organizations and challenged them to improve themselves. His ideas helped reshape how we percieve bureaucracy today, and have lead to a great deal of criticism which has increased our freedoms as individuals.
** I have distilled my theory of irrationality in an article known as Dialetic of Irrationality Revisted. Many scholars and friends have noted the flaws in this theory, but it does provide an interesting way to start criticizing the weakness of the increasingly bureaucratic world around us today.
Copyright ©1999-2008 Andy Arthur.
All mistakes are intentional or otherwise.
Mind where you step in a cow pasture or legal mindfield.